changingminds.org

How we change what others think, feel, believe and do

| Menu | Quick | Books | Share | Search | Settings |

Justification and Excuse

 

Techniques > Conversation techniques > Excuses > Justification and Excuse

Justification | Excuse | See also

 

When there has been a wrong-doing of some sort and somebody is accused, they may focus their defence on justification or excuse, which are quite different.

Justification

Justification is about giving 'reasonable reason' for what was done (or not). It considers the context and concludes that fair play was served.

In court, a justification defense concentrates on the act rather than the actor. It shows the act to be beneficial to society in some way. It shows it as sensible and just and what a good person would do. It offers exonerating circumstances that say 'It was right to do this in this particular situation.

Self-defense is a very common justification. Other justification arguments include (Dressler, 1988):

  • 'Rights' approach: It is sometimes morally justifiable to enforce a legal and moral right (even killing another person).
  • 'Lesser evil' or 'superior interest' approach: In balancing all interests, the choice taken was the best of a limited set of options, all of which were unpalatable in some way.
  • 'Forfeit' approach: The supposed victim has, by their actions, forfeited their normal rights (such as being an aggressive intruder).

Excuse

In court, an excuse defense concentrates on the actor rather than the act. It accepts the act may have harmed society in some way, but seeks to show that the person is not really to blame.

Excuses may show that the person's choice was limited and that the 'right' alternative was not available.

 

There can be a fine line between justification and excuse. It may be justifiable for a person to take an unused ladder that was leaning against a wall to use in saving someone from a burning building. It would not be justifiable if they grabbed the ladder and left the person who was using it stranded on a narrow ledge, yet may this be excused.

See also

Moore's Causal Theory of Excuse, Types of Reasoning

 

Dressler, J. (1987). Justifications and excuses: A brief review of the concepts and the literature, Wayne Law Review, 33, 1133–76.

Dressler, J. (1988). Provocation: Partial justification or partial excuse?, Modern Law Review, 51, 467–80.

Milhizert, E.R. (2004). Justification And Excuse: What They Were, What They Are, And What They Ought To Be, St John's Law Review, 78, 725-895

Wright, F. (2008). The Theory of Justification and Excuse, and its Application to Self-Defence, Journal of Commonwealth Law and Legal Education, 6, 1, 55–73

 

 

Site Menu

| Home | Top | Quick Links | Settings |

Main sections: | Disciplines | Techniques | Principles | Explanations | Theories |

Other sections: | Blog! | Quotes | Guest articles | Analysis | Books | Links | Help |

More pages: | Contact | Caveat | About | Students | Webmasters | Awards | Guestbook | Feedback | Sitemap | Changes |

Settings: | Computer layout | Mobile layout | Small font | Medium font | Large font |

 

You can buy books here

More Kindle books:

And the big
paperback book


Look inside

 

Please help and share:

 

Quick links

Disciplines

* Argument
Brand management
* Change Management
Coaching
+ Communication
Counseling
+ Game Design
+ Human Resources
+ Job-finding
* Leadership
+ Marketing
Politics
+ Propaganda
+ Rhetoric
* Negotiation
* Psychoanalysis
* Sales
Sociology
+ Storytelling
+ Teaching
* Warfare
Workplace design

Techniques

+ Assertiveness
* Body language
* Change techniques
* Closing techniques
+ Conversation
Confidence tricks
* Conversion
* Creative techniques
* General techniques
+ Happiness
+ Hypnotism
+ Interrogation
* Language
+ Listening
* Negotiation tactics
* Objection handling
+ Propaganda
* Problem-solving
* Public speaking
+ Questioning
+ Using repetition
* Resisting persuasion
+ Self-development
+ Sequential requests
Stress Management
* Tipping
Using humor
* Willpower

Principles

+ Principles

Explanations

* Behaviors
+ Beliefs
* Brain stuff
Conditioning
+ Coping Mechanisms
+ Critical Theory
+ Culture
+ Decisions
* Emotions
+ Evolution
Gender
+ Games
Groups
Habit
+ Identity
+ Learning
+ Meaning
Memory
+ Motivation
+ Models
* Needs
+ Personality
+ Power
* Preferences
+ Research
+ Relationships
+ SIFT Model
+ Social Research
Stress
+ Trust
+ Values

Theories

* Alphabetic list
* Theory types

And

- About
- Guest Articles
- Blog!
- Books
- Changes
- Contact
- Guestbook
- Links
- Quotes
- Students
- Webmasters

 

| Home | Top | Menu | Quick Links |

Changing Minds 2002-2014
Massive Content -- Maximum Speed